LeadStory

What is the controversy around Mexico's judges?

Asked 9 hours ago

Answer

Mexico's new system of electing judges by popular vote has sparked controversy. Critics argue it allows less qualified, politically connected individuals to become judges and claim the ruling Morena party has used the process to fill the judiciary with its allies. Supporters say it will reduce corruption and increase diversity, but concerns remain about judicial independence and the undermining of checks and balances.

Now Playing

Al Jazeera

Mexico swears in first elected judges amid political controversy

Al Jazeera · New
Al Jazeera
Al Jazeera
New
  • Mexico becomes the first country to elect its entire judiciary by popular vote.
  • Over 800 judges, including the first indigenous chief justice in 150 years, were sworn in. 16s
  • Concerns raised over ruling party Morena's influence on candidate selection and election results. 45s
  • Critics say the reform overlooks deeper issues in state prosecutor offices. 2m 14s
  • Half of judicial positions have been filled, with the rest to be elected in a future round. 2m 39s
Politics

References

Mexico swears in first elected judges amid political controversy
Icon
Al Jazeera
9 hours ago
Mexico swears in first elected judges amid political controversy

The process is criticized for being controlled by the Morena party, with 100% of elected Supreme Court and electoral tribunal judges having ties to the party.

Mexico tests controversial judicial reform
Icon
Al Jazeera
1 day ago
Mexico tests controversial judicial reform

The new system has opened the door to less qualified and experienced judges, some with dubious links, raising concerns about the integrity of the judiciary.

Mexico tests controversial judicial reform
Icon
Al Jazeera
1 day ago
Mexico tests controversial judicial reform

There is an underlying fear that many newly elected judges have strong ties to the ruling Morena party, potentially diminishing checks and balances.

Mexico elects first indigenous chief justice in over 150 years
Icon
Al Jazeera
2 days ago
Mexico elects first indigenous chief justice in over 150 years

Critics say the ruling party has politicized the judiciary, ensuring candidates aligned with Morena have been voted in, including the new chief justice.

Mexico justice system overhauled as judges elected by popular vote
Icon
Al Jazeera
3 days ago
Mexico justice system overhauled as judges elected by popular vote

A major complaint is that the election has been used to get the ruling party's preferred candidates into judges' chairs, raising concerns about judicial independence.

What Are People Asking?